Nobody who was there will forget the crazy conclusion to the Addicks’ hard-fought draw with the Tractor Boys. KEVIN NOLAN stayed until the end to bring you this report.

The announcement of six added minutes at the end of an entertaining but hardly barnstorming game gave little warning of the Keystone Kops conclusion that lay in store for all concerned.

Having surrendered a two-goal lead, Ipswich were understandably disappointed with the 2-2 scoreline; Charlton on the other hand, had salvaged a valuable point and could be satisfied with their afternoon’s work. First half injuries had robbed them of key defenders Mandela Egbo and Eoghan O’Connell but they had battled back gamely through adversity to achieve an uphill result. Or so it seemed.

What played out during those barmy six minutes (which actually stretched to almost ten) defied description. But since it’s my duty to have a go, I’ll make a game effort to find sense in the chaos which briefly descended on The Valley. So buckle up and make the necessary allowances for a less than objective version of events.

Reasserting the overall superiority they had enjoyed throughout normal time, the Tractor Boys appeared to have restored order when substitute Feddie Ladapo turned sharply to beat Joe Wollacott with a shot whiplashed inside the keeper’s right hand post.

A minute later, a more speculative drive from skipper Sam Morsy caught a faint deflection before settling decisively in the bottom right corner. As the jubilant visitors celebrated wildly in front of their fans, an unseemly exodus of home fans began to pour through the various exits. You couldn’t blame them but they should have known better.

More in hope than expectation, the stricken Addicks fought back. A free kick conceded by an oddly panicky Luke Wolfenden was flighted to the far post by Scott Fraser, returned along the ground by Corey Blackett-Taylor and stabbed past Christian Walton by full league debutant Terell Thomas.

The statutory six added minutes soon expired but the cocky East Anglians were made to pay for their self-indulgent goal celebrations. Referee Josh Smith didn’t get much right but deserves credit for knowing how to tell the time.

An early replacement for the wretchedly unlucky Mandela Egbo, Albie Morgan had provided sketchy support for beleaguered Sean Clare but going forward proved a force to be reckoned with. In almost the last act of this wacky race, the Marmite midfielder flighted a delicious cross from the left flanks, which was clearly intended for a flash of red lurking behind left back Leif Davis at the far post.

With caution thrown to the wind, the red shirt spotted by Morgan was worn by none other than George Dobson, widely admired for the yeoman shifts he puts in for the cause but, frankly, not the Addick many fans would choose to represent them in a death-or-glory situation such as this one. In 58 previous starts, George’s solitary goal was admittedly a superb matchwinner at Rotherham last season.

But as it turned out, Charlton’s fate was safe in his hands. Or head, to be more precise.

Rising majestically over Davis, Dobson had the presence of mind to assess Walton’s rash advance off his line and looped a deliberate header over the desperately scrambling keeper, which took its time before dropping neatly into his vacated net. Town’s hysterical celebrations were seen and raised by the human pyramid which took shape in front of the Covered End.

“Table’s turned and now it’s your turn to cry,” fitted the musical bill. My favourite Rolling Stones song, as it happens.

The added-time explosion had been preceded by a relatively normal but eventful encounter, dominated for most of its duration by Ipswich.

As Charlton struggled to cope without O’Connell and Egbo, it became vital that they survive an embattled first half without conceding. That ambition was thwarted in the last minute when George Edmundson bulleted Davis’ inswinging corner off Woollacott’s hand and under the bar.

Battling on gamely but apparently hopelessly, the Addicks looked down and out when, on 52 minutes, Tyreece John-Jules doubled their deficit by heading Wes Burns’ cross forcefully past Wollacott. But that was to reckon without the impact provided by perennial substitute Chuks Aneke and speed merchant Blackett-Taylor. Ben Garner’s objections earned him expulsion; he missed a treat.

Aneke was his usual irrepressible self, all but impossible to subdue and too strong for a tiring defence. Just past the hour mark, his powerful run down the right flank was capped by an enterprising cross, which Blackett-Taylor hammered against Walton’s hands.

Closing in alertly, Jesurun Rak- Sakyi forced in the rebound and, abruptly, Town’s comfortable afternoon was fraught with concern.

Blackett-Taylor had the bit between his teeth now and his crisp daisycutter was kept out with difficulty by the suddenly overworked Walton, whose luck ran out as Morgan hurriedly jabbed the loose ball past him. As rare a scorer as Dobson, Albie managed a decent celebration.

As did an ecstatic Valley, which was briefly able to forget that this brave result would have meant more if Charlton had done the business against Milton Keynes in midweek.

But that’s the way it is – there’s always a dark cloud inside every silver lining.

Charlton: Wollacott, Clare, Thomas, O’Connell (Lavelle 43), Egbo (Morgan 14), Rak-Sakyi, Fraser, Kirk (Blackett-Taylor 63), Dobson, Sessegnon, Stockley (Aneke 62). Not used: McGillivray, McGrandles, Payne. Booked: Dobson, Clare, O’Connell, Stockley, Garner-sent off.

Ipswich: Walton, Davis, Edmundson, Morsy, Wolfenden, Burns (Keogh 90), Chaplin (Harness 71), Ball, John-Jules (Ladapo 71), Jackson (Edwards 71), Donacien. Not used: Hladky, Vincent-Young, Humphreys. Booked: Ball, Burns, Morsy, Walton.

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch

The wheels fell off Charlton’s mini-revival last night with defeat at The Valley. KEVIN NOLAN was there to see it.

Charlton’s three-game winning streak, which had featured two buccaneering victories at The Valley, came to a shuddering halt on Tuesday evening, destroyed by a savvy Milton Keynes side which included in their ranks a contingent of Dad’s Army recruits.

Each of the old ‘uns made a significant contribution to a result that lifted MK off the foot of the League One table.

The seemingly endless one-club career of Dean Lewington, 38, has seen this estimable old pro add a few pounds here and there as he approaches 900 appearances.

He marshalled the visiting defence as they easily mopped up Charlton’s lumbering forays, hardly breaking sweat while calming nerves and smoothing one or two rough spots. Never ruffled, rarely in a hurry, he’s a chip off the still-functioning block which is his dad, the former Fulham midfielder Ray.

Ahead of Lewington in the heart of midfield, much-travelled Bradley Johnson, 35, put himself about, kept the ball moving – something Charlton miserably failed to do – and stepped up, with 12 minutes remaining, to put the seal on MK’s perfect evening by curling a magnificent free kick into the top right corner from fully 25 yards.

That Scott Fraser’s tackle on Dawson Devoy seemed eminently fair was clearly of no concern to the grizzled veteran.

A comparative fledgling at 31, Will Grigg struck the bar in the first half but was largely anonymous until midway through the second session.

Under Eoghan O’Connell’s thumb, he was freed from the Irishman’s grip when referee Neil Hair ruled that Ryan Inniss’ clumsy challenge on Louie Barry occurred inside, rather than quite obviously, outside Charlton’s penalty area.

From 12 yards, he made no mistake and celebrated with all the pent-up frustration he has no doubt nursed since being part of the Sunderland team which had their hearts broken by the Addicks three years ago. Revenge was long delayed but tasted no less sweet for that.

It came as a surprise to realise that Josh McEachran is still nine months short of his 30th birthday. He’s been around forever and has seen a fair bit. Probably in the early twilight of an up-and-down career, he can still produce an occasional killer pass, as he demonstrated with the glorious through ball which sent Barry goalside of Inniss to earn the contentious spot kick.

Insult was added to injury when a second yellow card brought dismissal for Charlton’s mammoth defender. For their part, Charlton were dreadful. Their manager Ben Garner’s puzzling decision to replace left back Steven Sessegnon with Sean Clare was hardly responsible for their turgid, laboured performance but it scarcely helped.

The uncomplaining Clare soldiered on but was clearly uncomfortable in his unfamiliar position. In front of him, young Tyreece Campbell did his best but was clearly out of his depth. He was replaced at half-time by Jack Payne with, it should be said, no marked improvement in quality.

On the opposite flank, meanwhile, Jesurun Rak-Sakyi was his, by now customary, mixture of mercurial ability and self-indulgent flashiness.

Wedded to the notion that playing from the back is the key to success, the Addicks struggled instead to cross the halfway line. The ball made its meandering way via Joe Wollacott to Inniss, square to O’Connell, back to Inniss, then for variety out to Clare or Mandela Egbo. Back again to Wollacott and repeat the process.

A total absence of momentum or pace made it easy for MK – even allowing for the old bones in their line-up – to insert spanners into their creaking works.

In an atmosphere more suited to a funeral parlour than the home ground of promotion aspirants, the first half petered out in subdued silence. Only when Nathan Holland outwitted Clare on the right byline before setting up Grigg to hit the woodwork was there even a hint of excitement.

It was quickly followed by the excellent, full-length save Wollacott made to deny Johnson’s well-struck effort to convert the rebound. The interval came as welcome relief to all but 400 of a disbelieving crowd.

The opening stages of the second session offered false hope of improvement. During an all too brief flurry, Charlie Kirk’s low cross critically eluded both Payne and Jayden Stockley before Rak-Sakyi’s fierce drive was beaten clear by Jamie Cumming.

But the burst of aggression fizzled out and Wollacott was again called into action to keep out Holland’s accurate shot. Back went the Addicks into their cramped, crabbed shell, in thrall to a style which clearly doesn’t suit them but is all the rage these days.

The visitors found them easy to handle and fed on their errors. The penalty and the free kick which decided the issue were both harsh but were also the direct consequences of Charlton’s hubris. These were not the up-and-at ’em tactics that routed Exeter and Portsmouth, nor were they the pragmatic methods which registered their first away win of the season at Shrewsbury.

This was recourse to the unimaginative drawing board on which Charlton constructed a string of seven league games without a win.

Bang-in-form Ipswich are next up at The Valley on Saturday. If the Addicks get it right, they might have a surprise waiting for them because Garner’s men are just daft enough to see them off.

Might be an idea to stop horsing around in their own penalty area, though. Just saying…

Charlton: Wollacott, Egbo, Inniss, O’Connell, Clare, Rak-Sakyi , Dobson (McGrandles 82), Fraser (Morgan 80), Campbell (Payne 46), Kirk (Sessegnon 72), Stockley (Aneke 72). Not used: McGillivray, Thomas.
Booked: Inniss (2)-sent off.

Milton Keynes: Cumming, Lewington, O’Hora, McEachran (Burns 86), Grigg (Eisa 79), Holland, Johnson, Barry (Devoy 75), Harvie, Lawrence (Smith 85), Jules. Not used: Ravizzoli, Tucker, Dennis.

Referee: Neil Hair. Official attendance: 12,328 (400 visiting).

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch

October might have only just begun, but yesterday’s draw at The Valley showed signs of a bleak winter ahead, writes KEVIN NOLAN.

Still likeable but less loquacious these days, Karl Robinson brought Oxford United to The Valley for what, with tongue slightly in cheek, could be described as a quasi-six pointer.

After only 11 games, Charlton are already more interested in results beneath them in League One than those of the pacesetters at the top end of the table. It’s already shaping up as a grim struggle as winter approaches.

The Addicks are an ordinary team who belong in the lower half of the division. It could get better, but don’t bet on it.

It was touching that Charlton’s matchday programme revealed that Robinson “has made no secret of his love for The Valley” but the news hardly came as a surprise.

As recently as last February, the irrepressible Scouser masterminded Charlton’s heaviest defeat of last season when his unfancied side completed a league double over Johnnie Jackson’s bewildered men. Their 4-0 romp was a fair reflection of the gulf in class which divided them.

Arriving on Saturday in 19th position and only one point behind their hosts, with a game in hand, the U’s started confidently and ominously moved into the lead after just 11 minutes.

Accepting Kyle Joseph’s pass in his stride, Marcus Browne made ground as the home defence showed little interest in challenging him, drew a bead from outside the penalty area and beat Joe Wollacott’s desperate dive with a crisp drive into the bottom right corner.

Though expertly executed by Browne, it was the kind of sloppy concession guaranteed to enrage both manager and fans. No doubt Ben Garner was tempted to add his voice to the outbreak of booing which greeted the setback.

He had his say in an “angry team talk” during the interval and, to be fair, drew the right response. Charlton’s second-half performance almost banished from memory their turgid contribution to the opening stanza. The bar had been, admittedly, set low.

Spared further damage as Marcus McGuane lamely rifled a clear-cut chance wide, Garner and an increasingly mutinous crowd grumbled through 45 minutes of tedium, during which only United’s obvious lack of ambition kept their side in the hunt.

Denied space and time by the visitors’ high press, they struggled to cross the halfway line but retired at the break only a goal behind and still, nominally at least, in with a chance. There was no way of knowing, at the time, that Robinson’s chaps had blown an excellent chance of putting this game beyond the reach of their labouring victims.

An enterprising but unsuccessful attempt to lob Simon Eastwood from 40 yards by Mandela Egbo hinted at a fresh attitude and when Jesurun Rak-Sakyi’s shot struck a defensive hand before trickling to safety off an upright, the previously unruffled visitors were wilting under unexpected pressure.

It was no longer against the run of play when the Addicks equalised 10 minutes into the second half. Rak-Sakyi made the early running with a shot charged down to Scott Fraser, whose instant return was blocked out to Charlie Kirk by Stuart Findlay.

Composed and calm, Kirk’s perfectly chipped cross from the left gave Jayden Stockley the simple task of heading past Eastwood from three yards. It was the skipper’s first goal of the season and reward for Garner’s introduction of Kirk at half-time.

Kirk’s undoubted ability to find room for accurate crossing was seen again to advantage when fellow substitute Miles Leaburn’s clever backheel sent him clear to deliver hard and low from the same position. Sliding in under Elliott Moore’s alert pressure at the near post, Steven Sessegnon steered inches wide of the target.

An end-to-end game had suddenly erupted, with Oxford more than ready to contribute. An heroic, last-ditch block from Ryan Inniss was required to prevent Joseph from finishing Matty Taylor’s cute lay-off, before a late flurry of chances went unconverted during a hectic conclusion to Charlton’s fifth 1-1 draw of this stuttering season.

Second-half substitute Billy Bodin began the sequence of misses by dancing in from the left, leaving the indefatigable George Dobson on his posterior, but shooting inexplicably over the bar from close range.

At the other end, Dobson was sent clear by Diallang Jaiyesimi’s carefully tailored pass but was unable to beat the advancing Eastwood. Which left the last word to Jodi Jones, whose 25-yard curler drew a fine, full-length save from Joe Wollacott when heading apparently unstoppably inside the keeper’s right hand post.

So a draw it was, Charlton’s sixth from 11 starts in a campaign of mounting frustration. Better than losing, of course, but scarcely the stuff of ambition. Seems we’re always stuck in second gear -with the handbrake on.

Charlton: Wollacott, Sessegnon (Chin 68), Lavelle (Kirk 46), Inniss, O’Connell, Rak-Sakyi, Egbo, Payne (Leaburn 46), Dobson, Fraser, Stockley (Jaiyesimi 87). Not used: McGillivray, Thomas, McGrandles. Booked: Dobson, Lavelle, Inniss.

Oxford: Eastwood, Long, Findlay, Moore, Brannagan, Browne (Gorrin 79), Bate (Taylor 63), Brown, Henry (Bodin 63), McGuane, Joseph (Jones 90). Not used: Brearey, Mousinho, Seddon. Booked: McGuane.

Referee: Robert Madley. Official attendance: 12,806 (1,058 visiting).

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch

After running rampant against Plymouth, Ben Garner’s Addicks came up short against a tricky Cambridge United side. KEVIN NOLAN rues some missed opportunities.

It was unrealistic to expect that Charlton would reproduce the panache they showed while demolishing Plymouth Argyle in midweek. Football doesn’t work like that, not often anyway and hardly at all when Charlton are involved. A kick in the teeth almost inevitably follows the kind of euphoria generated by Tuesday’s result. It goes with the territory.

Charlton’s dramatic fall from grace needs but also defies explanation. Passive to the point of inertia, they were as bland on Saturday as they were brilliant on Tuesday.

The second half, in particular, was an exercise in frustration as they struggled to contain a Cambridge side which were clearly delighted with a point but lacked the gumption to strike out for more. Having led at half-time, the Addicks’ share of the spoils smacked more of defeat. Against more ambitious opposition, that’s exactly what they would have suffered.

The visitors, no strangers to football’s dark arts, made their intentions clear without undue ceremony. Having won referee Carl Brook’s coin toss, they defied protocol and requested that their hosts attack their favoured home end in the first rather than the time-honoured second half.

Their statutory right, of course, but it irritated the locals and stated United’s intentions unequivocally. Beaten heavily in midweek while Charlton were outclassing Plymouth, Mark Bonner’s men were unwilling victims and planned to do anything, legal or otherwise, to assert their rights. And, to be fair, they’re a half decent team when their mind is put to it.

Charlton’s start to this crushingly disappointing game gave few signs of the tedium in store. They survived a first minute scare when Shilow Tracey’s fine cross was headed narrowly headed over the bar by Lloyd Jones before hitting back through Scott Fraser, who glanced Charles Clayden’s beautifully judged centre inches wide. When the lively Tracey made shooting space for himself but sliced wide, then Albie Morgan’s dipping free kick drew an outstanding save from Dimitar Mitov, it seemed we were in for an end-to-end tussle.

The exchanges were lively and included a perfectly judged pass from Morgan, which sent Jayden Stockley clear to drag a left-footed effort well wide of Mitov’s left post. It was far from a classic but was no shocker either and was decorated by a good goal five minutes before the break.

A bundle of energy as usual, George Dobson illustrated his dual value to Ben Garner’s side by breaking up an attack inside his own half before turning defence into attack by picking out Charlie Kirk alertly in motion down the left flank. Taking Dobson’s pass in stride, Kirk made ground and crossed accurately for Stockley at the far post.

Smart chest control set up a close range shot which was saved by Mitov but hung in the air long enough for Fraser to leap high and head simply into an empty net. At the time, a repetition of Tuesday’s tidal wave seemed on the cards. But how wrong we were.

Frankly, Charlton’s second half tactics were inexplicable. Against mediocre opposition, they put the brakes on and began that build-from-the-back routine, which has the same effect, at least from a personal point of view, of slate being dragged down a blackboard.

Almost in slow motion, the ball meandered from Joe Wollacott to either Ryan Innis or Eoghan O’Connell, out to Sean Clare or Clayden before making its way back, via Inniss or O’ Connell again, to Wollacott. Then repeat as necessary before booting it downfield. Far better, you might suppose, to employ the superior control of midfielders Morgan, Fraser and Dobson to protect the ball while moving it forward but it’s the modern way to pass backwards and sideways in a football version of Russian roulette, until the space diminishes and panic takes over.

Inniss and O’Connell, in particular, don’t appear to relish the responsibility and who can blame them? They’re defenders, as defined in their job descriptions, not midfield ballplayers. And Wollacott, an otherwise superb goalkeeper, might have an opinion on the subject. Shortly before the interval, he was almost caught in possession and cleared his lines with indecent haste.

Encouraged to believe they were in with half a chance, Cambridge drew heart from Charlton’s negativity and equalised before the hour. A threat to most League One defences, Sam Smith’s downward header from Adam May’s left wing cross was foiled by Wollacott’s improvised save with his feet. The rebound was returned by Tracey, whose effort on the run was heading off target until Harvey Knibbs turned it past Wollacott from three yards.

At which precise point, it might have been impossible to locate a Charlton supporter who was remotely surprised by the change in fortune – a change, in fact, which might have deteriorated from bad to worse had Wollacott not saved superbly from Knibbs’ low snapshot, then bravely recovered the rebound at the feet of a predatory Smith. United were more likely winners at that stage, a position of some strength but one which didn’t dissuade them from running through their customary repertoire of feigned injuries and snail-like substitutions.

Hard to understand, really. With an ounce more ambition, they could have returned to the Fenlands with all three, not just one, of the points on offer.

Charlton: Wollacott, Clare, Inniss, O’Connell, Clayden, Dobson, Kirk (Leaburn 72), Morgan, Fraser (Payne 72), Rak-Sakyi (Blackett-Taylor 62, Henry81), Stockley. Not used: McGillivray, Chin, Lavelle. Booked: Clare, Clayden. And, er, Garner.

Cambridge: Mitov, Williams, Digby, Jones, Brophy, Smith, Dunk, Okedina, Tracey (Ironside, 77), May, Knibbs. Not used: Mannion, Haunstrup, O’Neil, Lankester, Ibsen Rossi, Janneh.

Referee: Carl Brook. Att: 12,644 (792 visiting).

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch

Charlton’s first home match of the season ended with a welcome win for the Addicks. KEVIN NOLAN returned to the press box at a blazing hot Valley.

Having spent almost all of a torrid first half with their backs against the wall, Charlton re-emerged after the interval to carry the fight to ragged-trousered aristocrats Derby, scored midway through the second session and had enough about them to make their single strike count.

County were left to rue missed chances and a fatal lack of killer instinct. They paid a bitter price for failing to crown their effortless superiority with at least one goal because if football teaches us anything, it’s that there’s almost inevitably a price to pay for profligacy. Charlton missed a couple of sitters themselves but when the chips were down, they were sufficiently clinical on one critical occasion. And once was enough.

The momentum was with the Addicks as they broke swiftly after clearing the latest of Conor Hourihane’s numerous, dangerous corners. Picking up possession in his own half, Scott Fraser swept into the Rams’ half before finding Charlie Kirk close to the left touchline. Kirk’s deft flick sent Albie Morgan through to move into shooting range and force a desperate diving save from Joe Wildsmith. Following up alertly, Corey Blackett-Taylor made easy work of planting the rebound into an inviting net and Charlton had a vital lead they proceeded to defend stubbornly.

The early running was made exclusively by Liam Rosenior’s talented side, who had little difficulty in creating opportunities, but they had considerably more difficulty in converting them. To be fair to them, they faced, in new Charlton signing Joe Wollacott, a goalkeeper in outstanding form.

A string of splendid saves began with the instinctive reaction which kept out James Collins’ point-blank effort and was continued by Wollacott’s unorthodox response to a clever backheel from Nathaniel Mendez-Laing, a victim again when the resourceful keeper dived to reach his low drive as it headed towards the bottom right corner. And when Collins finally beat Wollacott a minute before the break, his crisp daisycutter rebounded back off the foot of a post.

Very little had been seen from Ben Garner’s men up front but Kirk was an intermittent threat, alertly but inaccurately trying his luck from distance after a slip from Curtis Davies, then producing the juiciest of crosses from the left which Jayden Stockley, despite making meaty contact, headed straight at Wildsmith.

Outplayed and outclassed, Charlton sheepishly retired for what was surely the rough side of new boss Ben Garner’s tongue. His message, however couched, was probably short but certainly less than sweet. According to Garner, nothing discussed and rehearsed in training had been implemented by his wayward charges – his only consolation being that they could hardly get worse.

But on the half hour, whether or not he realised it, he received a break which had much to do with Charlton’s dramatic second-half recovery. Preferred to George Dobson, last season’s player of the year, Conor McGrandles has shown promise but struggled to get into a game all but totally controlled by the visitors. Coming off worse in a shuddering collision with Korey Smith, the willowy midfielder suffered a head injury which forced his withdrawal and replacement by Dobson.

No criticism of McGrandles is implied in commenting that Dobson’s arrival immediately challenged County’s midfield domination. There was a subtle but noticeable shift in physical superiority that was to turn around the one-way traffic which threatened to engulf the Londoners. And Dobson was at the root of it.

On the right side, meanwhile, Blackett-Taylor began to use his blistering pace and leave hapless defenders in his slipstream. Shortly after the re-start, he ghosted past his marker and supplied Stockley with a precise cross, which the misfiring centre forward again headed straight at Wildsmith.

Rosenior’s East Midlanders had been duly warned that Blackett-Taylor was briefly on fire. Shortly after the hour mark, his speed and anticipation carried him into the perfect position to convert Morgan’s partially saved shot; significantly he was unaccompanied as he did so.

Soaking up pressure but no longer buckling under it, the Addicks were well served by full backs Steven Sessegnon and Sean Clare, a Mutt and Jeff pairing which resisted stubbornly while finding time to turn defence into attack. In front of them, Morgan continued his encouraging improvement, adding another on-target shot before the end, which Wildsmith saved with difficulty.

Late substitute Jack Payne was an energetic influence but it was the romantic introduction of Miles Leaburn which especially delighted the home crowd, Leaburn the Younger provided a keep-ball cameo which saw the Addicks over the line for a belt-and-braces victory. Their cause was boosted by the incredible mess Jason Knight made of Max Bird’s tape-measured cross. With Wollacott’s goal at his mercy, Knight almost deliberately headed yards wide.

Charlton: Wollacott, Clare, Inniss, O’Connell, Sessegnon (Lavelle 90), Morgan, McGrandles (Dobson 31), Kirk (Jaiyesimi 81), Fraser (Payne 81), Blackett-Taylor (Leaburn 80), Stockley (Clayden 90). Not used: MacGillivray. Booked: Sessegnon, Morgan.

Derby: Wildsmith, Cashin, Barkhuizen (Dobbin 70), Bird, Smith (Sibley 55), Roberts (Forsyth 84), Davies, Knight, Mendez-Laing, Hourihane, Collins. Not used: Loach, Thompson, Stearman, Oduroh. Booked: Mendez-Laing.

Referee: Chris Pollard Attendance: 17,046

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch

A deeply disappointed KEVIN NOLAN saw a 12th place finish in League One cruelly snatched from Charlton’s grasp on the last day of a season of stifling mediocrity. He gamely removed his tongue from his cheek and came up with the following report.

Sinking to previously unplumbed depths of ineptitude, not to mention incompetence, Charlton inflicted on nearly 2,000 followers a performance which should live in club history as a “day of infamy”. They were almost comically bad but were spared a hiding of historic proportions by their hit-or-miss tormentors, who squandered a lorry load of chances on their way to an emphatic 4-0 victory.

To be scrupulously fair, the Addicks might have scored one or two themselves. Town keeper Christian Walton pulled off a superb save to keep out Jayden Stockley’s first half header but should subsequently have been given no chance by Stockley, who managed to hit the bar from two yards in the second session.

And before moving on, we can’t overlook the mess Conor Washington concocted when presented with a gaping net by Walton and his dithering defenders as they treated Chuks Aneke’s lofted ball like a live grenade. Washington helpfully defused the danger by lobbing tamely over the top.

That last paragraph might have left readers with the impression that at some point during this acutely embarrassing exercise, Charlton actually made a decent fight of it. The uncomfortable truth is they were never in with a chance once their hosts sprinted into a two-goal lead within 11 minutes of the start.

Hungrier, sharper, quicker to every ball, the Tractor Boys were superior in every department. Their victims were no more than acquiescent dupes. Or dopes – take your pick.

At the painful end of Town’s opening onslaught was 22 year-old league debutant Nathan Harness, who had good reason to curse his luck. Young Nathan was horribly exposed as Tyreeq Bakinson was allowed time and space to tee up an unencumbered shot from just outside the penalty area and made the most of abysmal marking to find the top right corner.

Still reeling from the nightmare start, Harness, who was deputising for off-colour first choice Craig McGillivray, then left his line to confront Wes Burns, who was sent through the middle by Conor Chaplin’s defence-splitting pass, but was beaten by the lively wide man’s coolly slotted finish. At that exact point in the lopsided proceedings, only the hardest of hearts would have begrudged the novice keeper at least a grain of sympathy. It’s likely that his confidence had already been compromised by the clearance he shanked into touch while dealing with a criminally under-hit back pass before the first goal.

With friends like those he found in front of him, Harness had no need to look far for enemies. He’s young, he’ll get over it.

The instinctive reaction Walton produced to turn aside Stockley’s clever header from Adam Matthews’ perfect cross was the visitors’ only positive contribution to the first half.

Five minutes after the interval, they made a chaotic start to the second period by conceding for the third time. Largely responsible for their downfall was ex-Addick Macauley Bonne, regularly undermined during his stay at The Valley by the harsh criticism of his manager Lee Bowyer.

Possibly with a point to make and a score to settle, Bonne was a lively thorn in Charlton’s flesh and laid on Burns’ second strike with a perfect low ball from the left which gave Burns the easy task of sweeping home from close range. Bonne had already netted similarly in the first half but was ruled offside.

Blundering from one mini-crisis to the next, meanwhile, Charlton were woeful. Second balls were passively conceded, clearances were panicky and passing was, shall we say, less than precise. Substitutes Jake Forster-Caskey and Aneke replaced ineffectual midfielders Albie Morgan and Alex Gilbey to marginally positive effect but nothing really worked.

So devastating while rampaging down the left flank recently, Corey Blackett-Taylor was re-deployed at right wingback and, apart from delivering the delicious cross which Stockley wastefully headed against the bar, got nowhere. On an afternoon when none of Johnnie Jackson’s troops stood out, neither Akin Famewo nor Ryan Inniss put a foot right.

Skipper Jason Pearce at least cleared heroically off the goalline from Luke Woolfenden, whose talented skipper Sam Morsy contrived to scuff wide from 10 yards when neatly set up by Burns. Not that Ipswich were denied a fourth goal.

Blameless for the first three goals, poor Harness carried some of the blame for the shot which Bonne’s 85th minute replacement, James Norwood, squeezed home off the far post from a seemingly impossible position on the right byline. In mitigation, Charlton’s beleaguered debutant had received less than sturdy support from Famewo.

Norwood’s coup-de-grace provided a fitting end, not only to this dismal game, but to an equally dismal season.

Except to gratuitously single out Elkan Baggott. Youthful Tractor Boy Elkan put in a steady shift at the back but admittedly did nothing to warrant special recognition. But come on… Elkan Baggott – how often do you come across a magnificent name like that? So in he goes, lump it or like it.

Anyway, that’s me about done until we pick it up again in July. So unless you have something to add… that’s all folks!

Ipswich: Walton, Penney, Woolfenden, Burns, Bakinson, Bonne (Norwood 85), Chaplin (Humphrys 76), Celina, Donacien (Vincent-Young 56), Baggott, Morsy. Not used: Hladky, Pigott, El Mizouni, Aluko.

Charlton: Harness, Blackett-Taylor, Pearce, Famewo, Inniss, Morgan (Forster-Caskey 68), Gilbey (Aneke 54), Matthews, Dobson, Stockley, Washington (Lee 75). Not used: Henderson, Jaiyesimi, Burstow, Elerewe. Booked: Dobson.

Referee: Charles Breakspear. Att: 26,002 (1,972 visiting).

---

Thanks to Kevin for his reports this season. We’re glad to say he’ll be back next season, which begins on July 30.

---

LIKE KEVIN’S REPORTS? SUPPORT THE CHARLTON CHAMPION

– We publish Charlton Athletic match reports from home games. You can help us by becoming a supporter at presspatron.com/charltonchampion
– You can also support us via Patreon
– Can your company sponsor these match reports? Get in touch